On Giving Advice
By Kirk McCarley, As the parent of adult children, one of the disciplines I’ve tried to stick to has been refraining from giving advice. Without doubt I’ve fallen short of that aspiration at times. I have shared with my son, daughter, and their respective spouses that one of the greatest gifts they can give is the act of asking for advice. On those occasions where advice is sought interestingly, my responses are often rhetorical, where the first comment is to ask them, “what do you think you should do?” I aim to also say, “thank you for asking for my opinion.” To be viewed as a sage of wise counsel and thought is of highest esteem. Years ago, I worked for a mayor in a small community, an elected official. There was another office holder in a somewhat complementary agency who was garnering a reputation as being outspoken, surly, and often rude. It was vital that the two officials enjoy a compatible working relationship for the sake of not only their respective jurisdictions, but in serving the public well. The mayor shared his story. “I invited him to lunch. Once seated, as expected he went through a laundry list of things that he found disagreeable: road and bridge issues, law enforcement, and intergovernmental relations. His complaints could be wearisome, but again I was accustomed to his laments. Amid his soap box, came a sigh and a pause. He hesitated, turned towards me and asked why he was not achieving the...
Read More